Councilman Draws Flak for Bringing Forth Charter Change

The amendment to the city charter will strip the mayor of his power to appoint staff members.

A City of Canton council member brought forth an amendment aimed at removing Mayor Gene Hobgood's ability to appoint personal staff members during the tail end of Thursday's City Council meeting.

Councilman Bill Bryan would like to see paragraph F of section 2.35 of the current Charter of the City of Canton removed. This paragraph allows the mayor the ability to "select appointed or employed staff."

Currently, Hobgood has two city workers in his employ: administrative assistant Patricia Fowler and Canton Main Street director Ginger Garrard.

“It’s just not good practice for a part-time mayor to have a full-time staff,” Bryan said, to the Cherokee Tribune before yesterday's meeting.

Bryan began his speech by listing the times he and Hobgood had stood side-by-side on issues such as the decision not to sell the Hickory Log Creek Reservoir after he and Hobgood had eaten breakfast with Sam Olens while trying to figure out a way to sell the property. He also remnided the mayor how they had "met with Dr. Petruzielo in our joint effort to retain the county's largest employer," the Cherokee County School District.

Bryan stated in his presentation to Hobgood, "I don't hate you." He stressed the move as a money-saving action, and not as part of "a personal vendetta." Bryan said he had stopped by Hobgood's office twice recently to reinforce their working relationship, and offered to show the mayor all documentation regarding the proposed charter change.

However, Bryan still felt that it was fiscally irresponsible for a "part-time mayor" to have staff members, especially due to their full-time salaries; according to the Cherokee Tribune, Fowler makes $51,984 a year while Garrard makes $41,202. Fowler's salary is budgeted as part of the mayor's office while Garrard's is not.

"Tonight is only the first step in the deliberative process in this charter change that we have been discussing off and on for three years," Bryan said.

Another council member opposed Bryan's proposal and criticised the motion even being brought forward. Councilman Glen Cummins spoke out about his displeasure.

"The creating of the charter was a highly deliberative process, and should not be changed because a council member or members disagree with the mayor on whose decisions they are dissatisfied with," Cummins said, with applause from the audience.

In his speech, Cummins expressed his disappointment with Bryan for going back on his earlier support of the charter worked out with a citizens' oversight committee. Wording of the charter was altered to appease Bryan and gain a unanimous approval of the new charter.

Cummins also said that a member of the press had asked him why Bryan was bringing the motion before the body when Bryan had told the same press member that he would refrain from doing so as long as the mayor refrained from bringing up his idea to consolidate the Canton Fire Department with Cherokee Fire and Emergency Services, an agreement the mayor had confirmed to Cummins was in effect.

"He's [Bryan] just being vindictive, and you all know it," Cummins said.

Councilman John Beresford said that the speech given by Cummins against Bryan was a prime example of the "back biting" between council members that has plagued the body and given it a poor reputation with citizens.

Beresford felt ashamed that the infighting was continuing between council members, and said the attempt by Cummins to tie the current motion to the fire consolidation issue was erroneous.

"This is not a shot at what you're all trying to relate it to," Beresford said.

Bryan forgave Cummins for his "personal attacks," and said he had nothing but "respect and admiration" for his fellow council member.

For his part, Hobgood defended his appointments by stating that though his job description may only be part-time, he is on call 24 hours a day for the city.

"People come up to me all the time and ask me, 'What are we going to do about speeders on my street?,' or, 'Why can't we get better traffic control at Boling Park?'"

Hobgood gave out his personal phone number, although he thought that most of the audience already had it programmed into their phones. 

The motion to approve the amendment to the charter passed 5-1 with Cummins casting the lone dissenting voice.

hope November 16, 2012 at 02:59 PM
speeders? that's the example he decided to use? i will tell you what he's going to do about speeders on your street...NOTHING! you have seriously got to be kidding me hobgood. there's a reason my kids call you hobbad. because you laughed in our face regarding our neighborhood concerns about speeders. sell your story somewhere else.
Walsh family November 16, 2012 at 04:15 PM
Were you even at the council meeting, Justin Ove? "Wording of the charter was altered to appease Bryan and gain a unanimous approval of the new charter." Do you really believe that the councilmembers are irresponsible enough to vote yes on a issue as serious as doing away with a person's position simply to "appease" someone else (Bryan) who is not directly affected? And of course with Trish being retirement age, she will be receiving plenty of pension for her service. The point here is that no mayor in any Georgia city even remotely close to Canton's size (under 30k citizens - Canton has 23k) has staff working for him alone. It is not done, because mayors should be equipped to handle their own job and delegate as necessary. Simply false: "A motion was brought before the council by Cummins asking Bryan to withdraw his proposition, which passed 5-1, with Bryan the lone dissenting voice." The proposition was not withdrawn; instead it was passed. How is Bryan's practice of pointing out his support of the mayor "petty bickering"? Beresford was directly referring to the malicious finger-pointing and pithy attacks BY Cummings. Beresford voted FOR the charter change. It is a wonder this paper is still in circulation now that Rodney is gone.
Etowahwah November 16, 2012 at 05:17 PM
Yes, you got your facts wrong. Bryan had his "shadow council" lined up in agreement on this. He and his chronies came through on their vindictive threat to strip the mayor of his two staff members because he opposed the fire district. Tit for tat. Councilman Bryan is a disgrace to his office and to this city. There is now a total lack of confidence in this council to govern in a fair and consistent manner. Bill Bryan doesn't like something in the Charter, so he changes it to conform to his irrational and radical ideas. Oh, and he begins his motion with an inappropriate "poem." Far worse than Bryan's blatant disrespect is the the other Ward 2 councilman, Jack Goodwin, he just does what he is told and only speaks up when he is voting for an increase in salary or benefits for himself. Wake up Canton. Our city is in danger of losing all relevance, and thanks to Bryan's gang of five and Scott Wood's indiscretions, Canton has become the laughing stock of North Georgia. Bill Bryan is enough to make me miss Cecil Pruett!
Justin Ove (Editor) November 16, 2012 at 05:51 PM
Hello, I re-watched the meeting online (after watching it online live) and did realize I made mistakes in the original article that you pointed out. I have made the changes to more accurately reflect what was said last night. Thank you for keeping me honest. -Justin
Change For Canton November 16, 2012 at 07:02 PM
Canton Council is disgusting! They all need to be recalled. Since when do elected officials vote to not listen to the voice of a constitute? Decorum is out the door along with the best interest of Canton.
Keri Mullins November 17, 2012 at 02:03 AM
If a grown man can't answer his own phone calls and schedule his own calendar he shouldn't have taken the job...He just needs to deal with it.
People are Crazy November 19, 2012 at 05:04 PM
What the heck do these two women do to get salaries of this size from a small City? How much does the City Clerk make?? I think they need to do a revision of all salaries of City employees if this is the norm!!!! I don't have a clue what these people do, but to me those salaries sound a bit high irregardless of whether or not the Mayor needs help! What are their job duties? What is their education and experience? Geesh I really want to know this. Forget the back biting political crap. This is tax dollars going to them for WHAT??
Sandy McGrew November 28, 2012 at 05:43 PM
At some point the hiring of these two individuals, Mayor's admin assistant and Main Street director was approved. The salaries were approved. With hard times upon us I don't see a problem with asking them to take a reduction in salary. Budget cuts stink but are necessary sometimes. Sorry ladies. But you would still have your jobs. The city needs to do all it can to reduce it's debt. Spending $30k on Christmas decorations and $51k on a projector system for the Canton Theatre were not wise uses of our city dollars. Weighing peoples' jobs over Christmas lights, I have to choose the jobs. Try to make do with the decor we already have for one more year. As much as I love the Canton Theatre, and I really really do, $51k for a projector, right now just seems.....not quite right. At this time. And let me address the renovations to the "sanctuary" area of the city hall for council chambers. REALLY? Your current chambers are perfectly fine. Not especially attractive, but more than functional. I understand that repairs need to be made to the "sanctuary" roof and ceiling. But the renovations? NOT NOW. Work on the existing debt payoff.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something